Jenelle Potter was socially awkward and sickly. At the age of 30, she was still living with her parents who controlled every aspect of her life. When she met a well-liked young man, called Bill Payne, she fell head over heels in love. But the feeling was not mutual. When Bill met Billie-Jean Hayworth, he realised that he was ready to settle down with her. A jealous Jenelle could not handle it. When both Bill and Billie-Jean unfriended Jenelle on social media, she took drastic measures to get even with them.
For pictures and more information, join us on Facebook
Want to support our podcast? Visit our page at Patreon
For all sponsor discount codes, visit this page
Resources
The Murders of Billy Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth
Too pretty to live – How a woman convinced her parents and boyfriend to kill Facebook bullies
Judge denies mother and daughter’s requests for new trial based on information in prosecutor’s book
Facebook defriending murder: Jenelle Potter, daughter of accused killer had history of cyber fights.
Too Pretty to Live – The Catfishing Murders of East Tennessee
Created & Produced by Sonya Lowe
Narrated by Noel Vinson
Researched & Produced by Two Red Romans Productions
Music: “Nordic Medieval” by Marcus Bressler
Background track: Doblado Studios: https://www.youtube.com/c/DobladoStudios
This True Crime Podcast was researched using open source or archive materials.