Transcript: 75. Toxic Teen Love Triangle | USA

You are listening to: The Evidence Locker.

Our cases have been researched using open source and archive materials. It deals with true crimes and real people. Each episode is produced with the utmost respect to the victims, their families and loved ones. 

Warning: This episode contains direct quotes with explicit language. If you find profanity offensive, please be advised that words have not been bleeped out.

It was a balmy April night in Pinellas Park, Florida. A storm was brewing… A storm that had nothing to do with the weather. For months, two 18-year-olds, Rachel Wade and Sarah Ludemann were terrorising each other, stalking each other, making snide remarks and leaving threatening text and voice messages.

The reason for their relentless feud was Joshua Camacho. He was a player, and seeing both girls simultaneously fuelled the fires of their hatred towards each other. He was smooth and manipulative, but instead of leaving or confronting HIM about the issue, Rachel and Sarah chose to fight with each other. 

Neither one let an opportunity go to make the other look bad. The year was 2009 and all teenagers lived their online lives on Photos and mood updates were broadcasted to the world, exposing one’s inner-most thoughts. This was the perfect platform for Rachel and Sarah to claim Josh and to brag about their conquests of him. 

Their friends followed the feud and it became a form of entertainment. As soon as there were any updates or news, their friends told them and encouraged them to act. It was a teen soap opera with many characters.

Tensions rose until the early morning hours of April 15th, 2009 when they came face to face at last. With many of their friends watching, a physical altercation followed. Then there was blood-- a lot of blood. By the end of the night, one of the two was pronounced dead. 

>>Intro Music

Rachel and Sarah grew up in the working class neighbourhood of Pinellas Park in happy family homes with both parents. They were loved and cared for by their hard-working parents. Both attended Pinellas Park High School, but not at the same time, so they did not know each other. 

Rachel Wade came from a loving home. Her mom Janet was an elementary school teacher and her dad Barry a truck driver. She had an older brother and they had a stable home life. 

That is, until Rachel hit her teens. She became rebellious and got herself into trouble quite a bit. Her parents said that it soon became obvious that Rachel preferred chasing boys to chasing good grades. She always broke her curfew and often snuck out late at night. Once she was caught in the backseat of a parked car, having sex with a 19 year old. She was only 15 at the time and the boy was charged with a felony sex offence. In her sophomore year, Rachel ran away from home 14 times. Her parents always notified police and when she returned, and they tried their best to persuade her to stay. 

Rachel also had an angry streak and lost her temper easily. One night, after a verbal fight with her mom, she grabbed a knife from the kitchen drawer, ran down the hall and locked herself in the bathroom. Janet Wade was concerned that she might harm herself, but fortunately she didn’t. After the incident, Rachel ran away from home yet again.

Her parents were deeply concerned about Rachel’s behaviour and took her to counselling, which worked for a while. But ultimately, Rachel’s desire to be independent and free from family responsibilities was too strong. It was like she couldn’t wait to go off on her own. But not to live responsibly, but rather to work and party. And, of course, boys…

She loved flirting and because of her looks and fiery personality, it was always reciprocated. After Rachel dropped out of school, she moved out of her family home into her own apartment. She was able to support herself, thanks to her waitressing job. Rachel was proud of herself and the fact that she could take care of herself. On her MySpace page, her name was ‘Independent Chick’.

After she moved out of her parents’ home, their relationship was better. She was on good terms with her mom, her dad and her brother and went home every weekend for family dinner.

Sarah Ludeman was the only child of Charlie and Gay Ludemann. They moved to Florida from New York because they wanted to be somewhere safe and warm. The couple struggled to conceive and only had Sarah later in life. They doted on her, their entire lives revolving around the sweet, bright girl.

As a teenager, Sarah was close to her parents. Family friends joked and called her a daddy’s girl. Her mom, Gay, worked as a surgical nurse and her dad, Charlie, as a taxi driver. Sarah shared his love of country music. They rode along in his cab, blaring Keith Urban on the radio, singing along at the tops of their voices. Sarah loved singing and dancing and even joined her dad when he took up karate lessons.

As she grew up, Sarah wanted to go out more often, socialising with friends. It was difficult to let her go, so her parents enforced a strict 11pm curfew. Sarah did not like to be in trouble with her parents, so she hardly ever broke the curfew. She was tall and big boned, confident and outgoing, a good student with many friends. She never had many boyfriends, but never seemed to want one either. She was happy with who she was and where she was.

When Sarah was 16, she attended high school at Tarpon Springs. It had a veterinary medicine program and it looked like her future was all planned out. Sarah was a straight A student who took the bus every morning for the hour-long commute to school. She had some teen crushes on celebrities or sports stars, but was still quite naïve when it came to dating.

To most girls, Josh Camacho was very sexy: his curly dark shoulder length hair, his smouldering mouth and his sculpted upper body… He knew girls liked him and he had a confident way about him. 

Josh’s dad came from New York and his mom from the Dominican Republic – where Josh and his siblings were born. He had a large family with six brothers and a sister. He spent a lot of time with his older brother Jay and the pair soon racked up a reputation as players. Josh wanted to be just like Jay. Their male friends were amused by the fact that they could manage so many girls without getting caught.

Josh had a girlfriend, Erin Slothower. They had been together since 1999. In elementary school he wrote her a note saying: Do you like me? She replied with a note: Yes. It was a sweet an innocent romance that evolved and turned sexual when they hit their teens. 

By the time Josh was about to start his senior year in high school, he had fathered a child with Erin. They broke up when she was pregnant, because she was sick of Josh cheating on her. But because of their child, they continued to share a strong bond. Josh simply referred to her as his ‘baby mama’ and did not take on any parenting responsibilities. Although he didn’t pay a cent of child support, Erin allowed him to see his son as often as he wanted to.

When Sarah Ludemann was done with the 10th grade, she spent most of the summer with her friends, going to the movies and hanging out at Chick-fil-A. One day she saw the handsome Josh come out of the kitchen. He noticed her and winked at her. For Sarah, it was love at first sight.

She quickly fell in love with Josh, who flirted with her whenever they saw each other. Her parents were surprised when she announced to them that she no longer wished to go to Tarpon Springs and that she wanted to transfer to Pinellas Park High. They tried to persuade her to reconsider, but Sarah had made up her mind. She did not want to follow her lifelong dream of becoming a veterinarian, all she wanted was to be at the same school as Josh. They were not in a relationship yet and she did not tell her parents that he was the reason she wanted to change schools. 

When the new school year started, Josh noticed Sarah at Pinellas Park High, but ignored her. But outside of school, as soon as they were alone, he could not stay away from her. Josh was Sarah’s first kiss, her first boyfriend and she was happy with whatever Josh said or did. It didn’t take him long to realise the power he had over her and became very controlling of her. 

Sarah’s friends were concerned that she always obliged his every whim. For instance, he would insist she wore trousers, so other boys could not see her legs. She went out and bought herself extra trousers, as she never used to wear them before. She was used to wearing shorts or skirts, as she loved going to the beach. She lost 30 pounds in a short amount of time, all to look better for Josh. Her grades began slipping and her whole universe revolved around Josh.

She spent all of her time outside of school with Josh and saw him as the ‘bad boy’. On her phone, she had photos of Josh holding a handgun and another one of him smoking pot. Sarah even made video clips with looping rap music tracks over photos of Josh posing like a gangster, arrogantly showing off the back tattoo of his last name Camacho written in an Old English font. 

After graduation Josh did not go to college or have a steady job. He simply lounged around playing video games and smoking weed. That is when he wasn’t seeing Sarah or Erin or some other random girl whom he would charm into sleeping with him.

Needless to say, Sarah’s dad, Charlie Ludemann, did not like Josh. He even referred to him as ‘The Rat’. He could see his daughter was changing, but there wasn’t much he could do about it. He warned her, saying that Josh was bad news, but that only drove her further into his arms. Her mom, Gay, said this about Josh:

“There was always something about him that kept you thinking: was he good, was he bad?”

Charlie and Gay knew they had to accept Josh, or they would lose their daughter. Charlie invited him along to Tampa Bay Rays games and Gay tried her best to make him feel welcome in their home. But Josh didn’t quite go out of his way to make any sort of effort with them. Sarah’s parents hoped that the relationship would run its course and that their daughter would come to her senses eventually.

And cracks were starting to show in their relationship. They broke up a couple of times, or rather, Josh broke it off a couple of times. But because he was her first boyfriend, Sarah was completely consumed by her love for him and refused to let him go. She didn’t want to believe stories about him cheating on her and always felt that their relationship was special enough to fight for. 

In the first months of Sarah and Josh’s relationship, Pinellas Park police were called six times to intervene in public confrontations. Once Sarah and Josh were fighting, shouting at each other across an intersection. Another time, both of them had a heated verbal confrontation with Josh’s baby mama at a cineplex – she was eight months pregnant at the time. Josh had lied to her about where he was and she lost it. On a different occasion they bumped into each other in a parking lot and another fight ensued.

In July 2008, Sarah and Erin were actually together. They realized that Josh was sleeping with both of them and in Sarah’s parents’ minivan, followed Josh around town to catch him in the act of sleeping with someone else. Erin and Josh’s baby was in a baby seat in the back. Josh noticed the two girls and pulled over. They stopped too. He approached them and went to the driver’s side – Sarah’s window was rolled down. Erin jumped out of the car to confront Josh and as she made her way around the vehicle, Josh punched Sarah in the face. 

Charlie and Gay Ludemann were furious and wanted to press charges, but Sarah convinced them not to. They respected Sarah’s wishes, but Gay did follow up with police and asked what they could do to keep Josh away from Sarah. Sarah struggled to stay away from Josh however.

Then there was Rachel Wade… Josh knew her since elementary school and her ex-boyfriend was friends with Jay Camacho, so they were acquaintances. In the summer of 2008, they bumped into each other at a party and sparks flew. Rachel made a point of popping around to Chick-fil-A every so often to see Josh, and they began a fun but volatile relationship. 

Josh managed to juggle his two relationships pretty well. Sarah had an 11pm curfew and Rachel didn’t get off work at Applebee’s before then. He would spend the evening with Sarah, the good girl and end the night with bad girl Rachel. It was the perfect situation for a player like Josh.

Rachel’s friends felt she could have anyone she wanted. She was fun and pretty and independent… They could not understand her obsession with Josh, it was like she was under a spell. Josh often stayed over at her apartment during their on-again off-again relationship. Rachel even saw his dark side and told friends that he threatened her with a gun when she wanted to break up with him.

Two months into their relationship, Rachel became aware of the fact that Josh was still involved with Sarah. Rachel knew about Sarah, but Josh had told her they had broken up. This was not true. 

Rachel was under the impression that she was getting back together with Josh and was mortified to hear that he was still with Sarah. She saw pictures of them together on a beach on Sarah’s MySpace account and exploded with rage. 

Both Sarah and Rachel’s friends encouraged them to move on from Josh, as he was clearly a player who was stringing both of them along. But both girls were headstrong and in love.

Rachel was furious and left Josh, being quite vocal about her reasons for breaking up with him on her My Space page. She mentioned that she could do so much better. Then Sarah typed a comment, stating that JOSH was in fact the one who had found ‘someone better’. 

Rachel got Sarah’s phone number off of Josh’s phone, and left insulting voice messages, attacking Sarah’s appearance and the fact that she still had a curfew. Sarah refused to be victimized by Rachel and stood up for herself. The two teenagers began a bitter feud. They posted derogatory comments on each other’s MySpace accounts, sent each other insulting text messages and voicemails. It escalated as the months went on. Reportedly Josh fuelled the fires by telling each of them:

“If you love me, you’ll fight for me.”

Sarah would show up at the Applebee’s where Rachel worked as a waitress and together with her friends, would taunt Rachel. One night, Sarah saw Rachel at work, walked up to her and knocked a tray out of her hands. She also complained to Rachel’s manager, claiming that Rachel had spat in her food. Which Rachel had done. Sarah showed up one Thursday night for Karaoke and found Rachel was working. She changed the lyrics of her karaoke song, clearly directed at Rachel.

In a voice message to Sarah, sent on the 29th of August 2008, an angry Rachel can be heard saying:

“I’m guaranteeing you I’m going to murder you… You are a fucking fat bitch and I’m going to fucking kill you, I swear on my life.”

To make matters worse, Josh began spending more time with Rachel, moving in with her and sponging off of her. All the while he was still seeing Sarah on the side. But instead of seeing Josh for the player he was, the girls turned their anger towards each other. 

How their feud came onto police radar, was firstly when Sarah and some friends shot silly string at Rachel in the parking lot of a Taco Bell, as Rachel headed to her car. Rachel claimed that Sarah drove past her apartment and shouted: ‘Come on, fight me!’ Sarah in turn, told police that Rachel called her 20 times in the space of two hours, threatening her. But no one was physically harmed and there was nothing police could to but to try and convince the girls to put their differences behind them.

Both girls’ parents were unaware of exactly how bad things had become. Their friends knew that things were not looking good and tried to convince both of them separately to break up with Josh.

It became public knowledge. Everyone knew about the girls hatred towards each other. The more other teenage friends stoked the fires, the harder it became to back down. This was a big drama, an emotional chess game that played out publicly on MySpace for the most part.

Rachel had a history of stirring fights between girls. She had a sharp tongue and was quick to threaten potential rivals on the phone. But most of her peers did not take her threats seriously. They felt that she was all bark and no bite, because she never actually fought anyone. So when the feud with Sarah began, nobody was too concerned. They just thought Rachel had found a new target for her unrelenting rage.

It all came to a head on April the 14th, 2009. Josh had promised both Sarah and Rachel that he would see them that night.

When Sarah arrived home from school, she immediately went to the computer and logged into MySpace. Things had been rocky between her and Josh and she was very emotional. Like a moth to a flame, she went to Rachel’s page and read her mood update. It said ‘Lovin my boo’.

Sarah immediately texted Josh. She sent a string of three messages, saying:

“Whatever Josh, you get so mad at me for everything but you don’t give a shit when she puts something up or says something. You always believe her.”

“It’s like no matter what I do She’s always that much better.”

“All we fight about is her or something that has to do with her, and it sucks. I hate fighting with you… I love you so much, but this shit hurts.”

Five hours passed with no response from Josh. Sarah sent another text:

“You say you love me, but you don’t even have the decency to text me back?”

Almost two hours later, Josh finally replied, only saying:

“Bring the movies.”

That was enough for Sarah. She borrowed her mother’s minivan and left to meet Josh at his sister Janet’s place to watch movies. But before she left, she made a point of updating her mood on MySpace. She said: ‘iloveyoubaby’.

Rachel had the evening off work and was home alone, waiting for Josh. But he never showed. She texted him, asking where he was and he said that he had to babysit his sister’s baby. As it was turning dark, Rachel decided to take her dog for a walk. She later told police that a car drove past, honking its horn. She heard Sarah’s voice shouting: 

“Stay away from my man!”

A neighbour also corroborated that someone was outside Rachel’s apartment, shouting similar statements earlier that evening.

This unnerved Rachel, so she called another ex-boyfriend, Javier Laboy. He told her to come over to his house, because no one would have thought of looking for her there. On her way out, Rachel turned back and fetched a steak knife from the kitchen and stuffed it into her purse. Later she said that she was scared and worried that Sarah and her friends would attack her, she only took the knife to scare them off.

Instead of heading straight to Javier’s, Rachel drove past at Josh’s sister’s house. She saw Sarah’s mother’s minivan in the drive and knew why he blew her off. Josh and Sarah were inside playing video games. Rachel sent him a text:

“Now I know why you're not talking to me — because you got her." 

With Sarah sitting next to him, Josh made sure she knew he was texting Rachel.

"That's right. I don't like you no more. Why are you down this street? Go home!" 

Rachel refused to leave and sent another text, saying:

 "No. I'll wait for her to go home."

Rachel left eventually and arrived at Javier’s house sometime between 11pm and midnight. They hung out with another friend, Dustin Grimes. Rachel told them about the knife in her bag. The friends later recalled that Rachel said she was going to kill Sarah, but Rachel denied ever saying this. She said she told them she brought the knife for self-protection and that Javier and Dustin promised her that she was safe with them and wouldn’t need it.

Just before midnight, Sarah agreed to give Josh’s sister a ride to McDonald’s, on her way home. It was past her curfew and her dad was getting antsy, sending angry texts, telling her to come home. 

On their way to McDonald’s, Sarah received a phone call from Rachel and put the call on speaker. Janet Camacho and her friend Jilica Smith were in the car and heard Rachel’s rant. Rachel reportedly threatened Sarah, telling her that she was going to stab her and ‘her Mexican boyfriend’.

As they drove, they came across one of Sarah’s friends named Ashley Lovelady at a street intersection. Ashley told them that she had just seen Rachel around the corner, on 52nd Street, at Javier’s house. Sarah clicked into action and decided to go there to confront Rachel and shut her up once and for all.

When Sarah arrived at Javier’s house, Rachel, Javier and Dustin Grimes were outside. Rachel was sitting on the hood of her car, a Red Saturn, smoking a cigarette. According to Rachel, Sarah nearly ran her over as she pulled up and brought her car to a screeching halt, five feet from the front of Rachel’s car. 

Sarah then got out of the car and Rachel later recounted ‘with fists flailing’. Rachel pulled the knife and made sure Sarah saw it, but Sarah did not back down, adamant to get to Rachel. She pulled at Rachel’s hair, pushing her head down, with Rachel’s arms waving as she tried hitting her. Then the balance of the fight turned and Rachel obtained the upper hand. She launched her attack on Sarah. First, she cut her on her shoulder, then stabbed her twice in the chest, a wound that punctured Sarah’s heart.

Other witnesses said that Sarah only just got out of her car and that Rachel attacked her before she had a chance to defend herself. One thing witnesses did agree on was that the fight flared up rapidly and ended very quickly. 

As Rachel ran away, she threw the knife into a neighbour’s roof, saying:

“I’m done.”

Javier Laboy remembered that Rachel had a blank look on her face. He said:

“It didn’t look like she was there with us.”

Janet Camacho’s friend, Jilica Smith was the first person at the scene who called 911. She screamed in shock: 

Rachel just stabbed her…”

As Sarah was dying, she shouted for Janet to get back in the car, to think of her children and protect herself. Sarah crawled back to her mom’s minivan to get to her phone and called Josh to tell him what had happened. Her last words to him were ‘…it hurts’ before she lost consciousness. When Josh was told what had happened, he ran to Sarah’s house to tell her parents about the attack and the three of them rushed to the scene. 

Charlie Ludemann saw Rachel sitting on a bench on Javier’s front porch, smoking a cigarette and marched up to her. He later recalled:

“I said Rachel, why – you stupid bitch, why couldn’t you fight with your hands. And Sarah’s layin’ there in a puddle of blood.”

Rachel had no words. 

Sarah passed away that night and was pronounced dead at the hospital at 2:29am. She died due to heart puncture. Her parents went to the hospital where doctors tried their best to revive her. Josh was there too, but he refused to go in to see her one last time. His reason was that he didn’t want to ‘see her like that’. To which Charlie Ludemann said:

“You are the reason she’s like that.”

The Ludemann’s blamed Josh for dragging Sarah into this toxic love triangle. She was not the kind of girl who ever went looking for trouble before she knew Josh. And because of him, they lost their only child forever.

Police were dealing with a homicide case and set out to question all the witnesses at the scene of the fight, including Rachel. When police arrived, she was still sitting on a bench on the front porch of Javier’s home. She was unaware of the fact that Sarah was no longer alive.

Officers took her to Pinellas Park police station, where they asked her to explain what had happened to cause the fight. Rachel told them her version of events leading up to the confrontation with Sarah, all the while not knowing that she had killed her. When interrogators told her that Sarah had died and that she was being charged with second degree murder. Rachel cried: ‘Oh my God!’ and burst out in tears of disbelief and horror.

Bail was set at a half a million dollars. She stayed in remand in the Pinellas County Jail until her trial was over. 

According to Captain Sanfield Forseth he came to the understanding that it was more than a love triangle – it was a ‘love hexagon’ as he called it. He was quoted saying:

"There's so many dynamics, so many people involved… The one center of gravity seems to be Joshua Camacho."

Sarah’s funeral was held a month before her prom. Josh was asked NOT to attend the funeral.

Rachel Wade’s trial began on the 20th of July 2010 and was televised on TruTV’s show ‘In Session’. Although she had just turned 18 at the time of the crime, Rachel was tried as an adult. Many Pinellas Park teenagers attended the trial – friends of Sarah’s, as well as Rachel’s friends.

Prosecution’s job was to prove that Sarah’s death was a case of pre-meditated murder. The history between the two young women and their arguments over Josh Camacho were laid out for the jury to consider.

Defence argued that under Florida’s ‘Stand-Your-Ground’ law, the murder was a case of self-defence. Not long before Rachel’s trial in 2010, Florida’s self-defence law had changed to ‘Stand your ground’. This means that if you are under attack, you reserve the right to defend yourself and answer with force. If you believe your life is under threat, you can use deadly force. However, Rachel brought a knife to a fist fight, so it wasn’t quite ‘Stand your ground’.

Javier testified that on the night of the murder, Rachel and Sarah were fighting when the stabbing occurred, although he did not see the entire incident. Rachel said that Sarah and two friends attacked HER. She was hit on the head three times. Only then did she reach for the knife in her purse and stabbed Sarah in an attempt to protect herself. Stabbing blindly, she did not mean to kill her. It was only when one of Sarah’s friends told her that she realized what she had done.

Josh’s sister Janet (who reportedly attacked Rachel along with Sarah) as well as Dustin Grimes testified that it was Rachel who walked over to Sarah and attacked her.

Josh testified and under oath he admitted that he was not serious about Rachel OR Sarah. He saw them as 'friends with benefits’ and did not have exclusive relationships with either of them.

The county coroner took the stand and said that it would have taken severe force to penetrate Sarah’s heart with the type of knife that Rachel used and concluded that it was done intentionally. The prosecutor also pointed out that blade of the knife was bent – an indication that the attack was fierce and violent.

In the end the most damning evidence against Rachel was her own voice. Voicemails saved by Sarah on the night of her murder sealed her fate. 

“I’m gonna find you and I’m gonna beat your ass. He can get anything he wants from me. You still got your mommy and daddy’s curfew, bitch. Why do you run your fucking mouth? And why are you that pathetic? So, keep talking, shit Sarah. I’m gonna fucking teach you. I’m telling you now.”  

And even more damning was Rachel’s reaction after seeing a photo of Sarah and Josh in New York on Sarah’s MySpace page. This was eight months before Sarah’s death:

“Please tell me, Sarah, why you would be a dumb ass cunt and put a fucking brand new picture of you and Josh at the beach on your MySpace? I’m gonna fucking murder you, I’m gonna play your ass out too. Watch! You’re a fucking fat bitch and I’m gonne fucking kill you.”

There was no coming back from that. The jury deliberated for two and a half hours only and returned with a guilty verdict. Rachel Wade was convicted of murder in the second degree. When the verdict was read, Rachel collapsed in tearful agony.

She apologized to Sarah’s parents, stating that she never meant to cause her physical harm. But Gay Ludemann didn’t buy Rachel’s remorseful apology. She asked the judge for a life sentence. With her, she had framed photographs of Sarah with her. She showed them to the court and said:

“This is my daughter. She lays in a cemetery. I go visit her there. Rachel Wade’s parents can come and see her.”

On Friday the 3rd of September 2010, 20-year-old Rachel Wade was sentenced to 27 years in prison. The judge said that he believed Rachel intended to kill Sarah. His statement:

‘This murder was no accident. It took a lot of force to plunge that knife through skin, through fat and bone, through someone’s heart.’

Rachel maintained that it was self-defence and appealed her conviction. She claimed that she was not the only one who left threatening voice messages. The difference was that Sarah saved hers, whereas Rachel deleted the ones sent to her. Rachel lost her appeal.

The case became a cautionary tale of how things can escalate with modern communications technology. Rachel’s defence attorney, Jay Herbert encouraged Rachel to teach young people about the dangers of social media. In a statement to CNN, Herbert said:

“When you start looking at the tragic nature of this, this social networking, the instant messaging, the ability to hide behind the screen and make statements and create situations – it just festered until it bubbled up and exploded into a situation. Until two good girls… Their worlds collided… And that’s the lesson for parents. Pay close attention to your children. Watch how they talk and who they talk to. Watch their social networking outlets. Because it’s an explosive situation when you don’t have to be accountable, when you can break up with somebody or somebody to prom via text.” 

If it weren’t for cell phones or the internet, then Rachel and Sarah would not have been able to perpetuate their fights. Hiding behind a screen made both of them more confident, perhaps meaner than they would have been face to face.

In the years following Rachel’s trial, on his parent’s insistence, she moved to live with relatives in New York. Many people felt that Josh, being at the centre of the whole tragedy, had to be held responsible in some way. But police had no grounds for charging him. In the eyes of the law he had done nothing wrong. Unfortunately, you can’t charge someone with being a player.

Charlie and Gay Ludemann filed a wrongful death suit against Josh Camacho for $15,000. This was to cover funeral costs, medical bills and compensate them in some way for their loss. Nothing, of course, would ever bring Sarah back.

Rachel is currently serving her sentence in the Lowell Correctional Institution. In an interview with Candace de Long in the Crime and Investigation series Facing Evil, Rachel said:

“I wish that we could have sat down and talked and figured out that we were worth more… And just walked away from him or confronted him with the situation before we confronted each other. And I wish that, you know, both of us could have been smart enough just to walk away and to realise we deserve better.”

Rachel says that she often speaks to Sarah’s spirit and begs her for forgiveness. She hopes to marry Javier Laboy when she is released from prison.

This story is a tragic one with two young lives lost. Sarah’s parents will never see her again and Rachel will spend most of her life behind bars. She will be released in 2035 at the age of 45. And for what?

If you’d like to read more about this case, have a look at the resources used for this episode in the show notes. 

Also visit and like our Facebook Page at” to see more about today’s case.

If you like our podcast, please subscribe in Apple Podcast or wherever you get your podcasts. We would also appreciate if you could review the episodes, as it gives us some street cred in the world of podcasting. 

This was The Evidence Locker. Thank you for listening!

©2019 Evidence Locker Podcast

All rights reserved. This podcast or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or used in any manner whatsoever without the express written permission of the publisher except for the use of brief quotations in a podcast review.